nice cabinets (and pin) Jay.
Here's my list:
1887 Oshkosh Team Cabinet - Composite
1887 Oshkosh Team Cabinet (w/ McCarthy) - new to my checklist (thanks)
1891 Boston BB Club Cabinet
1896 Boston Sunday Herald Team Art Supplement
1896-97 Whitehead & Hoag "On Time Starch" Pin
1897 Sporting Life Cover
1897 Elmer Chickering Boston Nationals Team Cabinet
1899 Elmer Chickering Boston Nationals Team Cabinet
1903 W601 Sporting Life Chicago
1904 Allegheny Card Co.
There just aren't alot of options for Selee. I was floored when I saw that near complete set of "On Time Starch" pins last year and saw Selee hiding in there. So cool. Congrats on the pick-up (again). And congrats on the new Oshkosh cabinet.
Here's my 1897 Sporting Life Magazine w/ Selee on the cover: