[Moesalty]

The same thing happened to me on eBay with a 1952 topps Mantle PSA 2. When I received it, I didn't like the look of the card. I went on YouTube and learned just how easy it to pop open a psa holder. At one point, there was an authentic Mantle in the holder, but was replaced with an obvious reprint.

EBay and paypal could do nothing to help me, but thank God that all my major purchases through paypal are paid for through Amex. One phone call and 24 hours later I got my money back. Amex also helped me and put me in contact with the authorities.

I still have the card and look at it often to remind me that "good" deals aren't always good!