[Archive]

Posted By: howard

No doubt Kauff and Williams had great years but Kauff did not play CF full time until the following year and Williams was a LF. I would take Mantle's '56, '57, and '61 seasons and probably a couple of Mays' seasons over Dimaggio's best. I'd also take '27 Gehrig over '32 Foxx but that's like comparing apples to oranges.

Howard

P.s. - I agree that several of Bonds years could be on the list.