I had an auction house submit both Harridge/Giles cards. I tend to agree with your opinion though I do think the harridge you do not like could be good as I have seen some other late in life signatures of him like that but could be forged
These were submitted to PSA and JSA. One of the companies liked both Harridge but rejected both Giles, the other company said both Giles were good but rejected the Harridges. Jim Stinson agreed with us (one good and one bad on each card). This is what makes the hobby so frustrating. Thanks for your input. Any opinion on my 1936 Tigers scorecard in a separate post in this section?
|