Posted By:
BobI have sure seen some wide swings in grading CJs- I have seen some which look vg graded as PSA 1s and cards which looked fairly well thrashed being PSA 3s. It is hard to tell from the scans but I see more condition variance in grading CJs than in any other set. Also the staining from the cracker jacks seems to have very little effect when it comes to grading, which I have never understood as some of the PSA 4s and 5s have horrible eye appeal with all the staining. I guess to each his own...