Quote:
Originally Posted by bnorth
Positive feedback should be left. This whole thing is 100% the OPs fault because he failed to read the description. It really sucks for the seller because they just lost $ on the transaction.
Several sellers use stock photos and as long as they have a great description like the seller in this case I do not have a problem with it.
Like Al I collect error cards and have done the exact same thing as Tom(OP) and Al and bought the card without reading the description. I handled the situation differently and owned MY mistake. Now make sure I read the description.  |
I have to disagree. This is not 100% the OP's fault. The card described in the listing is "Good". I don't think anyone that has collected cards of any kind longer than 10 minutes would ever consider the condition of this card as "good". He had drawn on then erased Devil horns and goatee for goodness sake!
Now, I will say that because grading is subjective, on persons "good" is maybe going to be better or worse than another persons. I made the mistake of buying a card this way once and the seller gladly let me return the card. I have since made subsequent purchases but I always request scans of the actual cards first. If a seller is not willing to provide actual scans, I move on.
Glad the situation worked out in the end and I agree that either no feedback be left or what I believe appropriate, is to leave positive feedback but note the card was not as described but the seller took care of you.