Posted By:
Judge Dred (Fred)Joe,
You've got to love this stuff. Some guy on a cabinet with a Detroit address. People think it's from the 1880s but can't be sure if it's one player or another.
Quite honestly, I'd trust your assesment and judgement on this rather than the people who claim to know or think they know who it is. You have more experience with Detroit players from that era than most people.
What do you think about this cabinet?
Is it possible that it's just some guy that had his portrait taken at a studio? Could it be Cap Anson... (snicker, snicker)?