ok here's the deal, with the typical talk of accuracy and value aside since that's been talked to death...sgc and psa have their own sets of grading standard that differs from each other (i'm not going to count beckett because in my mind they are still not very competent with pre/postwar).
if your corners are one way you should be going with one company to max the grade. if you have paper loss or slight wrinkle or centering or tack hole etc etc all these variables play differently for sgc and psa. there's no such thing as "the most accurate" grading, only the most favorable. so it all comes down to which grading company your standard lines up with and whcih company you feel comfortable having your cards holdered in. there are more than one grading companies for a reason, don't close yourself off to just one people.
|