Posted By:
Jason Lhow Kirby gets such short shrift on among those on this Board and elsewhere.
is it the short career, some psychological chip on the shoulder regarding potential for sympathy voting, or both?
I say Kirby certainly belongs.
Some who are questionable (keeping in mind that older era player identifications are merely stat driven and I have no real context):
Evers
Tinker
Mazeroski
Sutter, Gossage, Fingers (relievers have no place, sorry. I agree with a post above, -They just hardly ever play)
who might belong:
Reulbach
Cravath
O'Doul