Having decided to keep the card, I sent an email to the seller today asking for a partial refund (25%). He politely sent an email pointing out he didn't know the card's borders were recolored and doesn't like or believe in the grading companies in general. He also mentioned that the card was G/VG in its description (I missed that somehow) and so it was a good deal based on its SMR. He also pointed out that had it been graded SGC 50, I wouldn't have sent him the difference in value from G/VG to VGEX. Oh well, I tried.....
Thanks everyone for responding!
