[Archive]

Posted By: Howie

First off you have to positively identify if the card has been trimmed or if it's just an odd miscut that the grading company didn't want to grade. Sometimes they'll lump them in the trimmed reason for not grading. A better explanation of why this card wasn't graded should be sought. The odd cut could be a result of a miscut and not a trim job. Trimmed=Refund and Miscut=No Refund.

Second, the issue that the card might be switched or modified really isn't in question. A great picture of the card is still seen on Ebay. Look and compare, it's either the same or it's not.

Third, you just can't plead "just a broker" anytime something like this comes back and bights you. You're responsible for what goes through you. Your customers are buying based on your excellent reputation and assume you know about what you're selling.

Fourth, California law explained by somebody else above.