I'm glad you posted about these Shoeless and that you contacted ebay Wrapperguy. I saw them recently too - and had this exchange with the seller.
ME1: Das sind wundervolle alte Stifte! Wie lässt du aussehen?sie aussehen?
aussehen??Kannst du einen für 1939 Cincinnati Reds machen? Vielen Dank
harsenm_nn:1: You can write in english, I am afraid I don´t understand the translation
ME2: haha okay. I will. I say these are wonderful pins. They look old - can you make one for the 1939 Cincinnati Reds? thank you.
harsenm_nn2: What do you mean; I don´t make pins, I trade them
ME3: But aren't these made to look old? I assume you make them as they arent the actual pins that were issued for the games.
harsenm_nn3: no, they are not made to look old bud...
END OF EXCHANGE
When I did a google search for the image on his ebay profile I seem to get a stock photo of sorts....
https://www.google.com/search?tbs=sb...aSI4B5NWc7lF1g
I'm not sure why if he thinks they are real, he is so happy selling them for thousands less than they are worth. Sigh.