[orly57]

Originally Posted by irv

Would have both of these cards, in number sequence, (98, 99) been graded by the same grader?
Personally, I give up trying to figure out card grading!
http://www.ebay.ca/itm/1952-TOPPS-ED...kAAOSwr7tZgqgH

Irv, it's the same card. It's the same serial number. It WAS in an old psa holder at a 5. Then it was sent to re-slab and psa left it at a 5 rather than correcting the mistake. It's not a big deal, because, after all, they are human.