This might be helpful--at the bottom of this post is a copy of the same photograph, sold a few years back by Huggins & Scott, with the names written beneath.
1. Jesse Tannehill (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
2. Emslie (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
3. Unidentified--possibly Umpire Stafford (RUKen)
4. Gilligan (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
5. Jack Barry (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
6. Harry Lord (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
7. Fred Lake (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
8. Bill Dinneen (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
9. Dave Sheen (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
10. Charlie Farrell (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
11. Kip Selbach (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
12. Clyde Engle (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
13. Patsy Donovan (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
14. Jimmy Collins (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
15. Candy LaChance (RUKen)
16. Freddy Parent (RUKen)
17. Cy Young (Tony Andrea)
18. Heinie Wagner (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
19. Jack Hoey (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
20. Buck O'Brien (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
21. Olaf Hendriksen (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
22. Tommy Madden (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
23. Bill Carrigan (Brian Van Horn)
24. Ray Collins (Brian Van Horn)
25. Patsy Dougherty (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
26. Rafferty (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
27. Nick Altrock (AJ)
28. Paul Radford (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
29. Ex-Mayor Fitzgerald (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
30. Lt. Governor Fuller (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
31. Mayor Curley (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
32. Governor Cox (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
33. Tommy Bond (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
34. Jesse Burkett (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
35. (Jim?) Manning (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
36. Jack Chesbro (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
37. Tom Smith (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
38. Bill Bradley (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
39. Johnny Evers (BMarlowe1)
40. Jimmy Archer (in CUBS uniform) (RUKen)
41. Wood (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
42. Ted Lewis (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
43. Bobby Lowe (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
44. John Anderson (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
45. Kid Nichols (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
46. Ted Klobedanz (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
47. Bill Bergen (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
48. Tommy Tucker (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
49. Merritt (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
50. Woodcock (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
51. Nap Lajoie (AJ)
52. Bill Sweeney (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
53. Goode (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
54. Connaughton (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
55. Bannon (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
56. Billy Hamilton (RUKen-Huggins&Scott)
Here is a link to that auction:
http://mar07.hugginsandscott.com/pl/...ball_photo.jpg