[Archive]

Posted By: Hal Lewis

Feller was great... but so was Koufax for a short time.

While we can assume that Feller would have been dominant in those 4 years he missed... and while we can applaud his reason for missing them...

we can't change the fact that he missed them.

WHAT IF he had suffered a career-ending arm injury during those years?

-------------------------------

I was trying to determine which pitchers had the BEST CAREERS...

not necessarily which pitcher I would want on the mound for a ONE GAME championship in which the pitcher must be great but only for that one game.

I agree that Walter Johnson would be in my Top 5:

Mathewson
Grove
Clemens
Johnson...

and one other. Don't know who yet.