[wolf441]

Originally Posted by rats60

Wagner and Plank would still only have 1 card each. I would put the Plank around the value of the big 3 pitchers, maybe slightly lower. I think that Wagner would still be the most valuable hofer, slightly more than the green Cobb. Collectors would only have one Wagner pose to chase vs. 4 Cobb poses to pick from.

Someone mentioned it already, but I think if Wagner and Plank had no issues with being included in a tobacco set, we'd most likely see 3-4 different Wagner poses (maybe two portraits and a batting and fielding) and 2-3 Planks (portrait and maybe two different pitching variations). Given their status in the game at the time, I'd equate Wagner maybe a step below Cobb and a step above Lajoie. I'd put Plank right in the group with Brown and Bender. Given that, you'd think that they would have a similar number of poses to choose from. They would also most likely then have been included in the T205 set as well. I think Wagner's cards would be a little less than Cobb but higher than anyone else in the set. I'd think Plank would be most comparable to Bender in value.