1949 Pittsburgh Page's Milk - which one to keep

[Leon]

So my dilemma is which one to keep? On one hand I like HOF'ers, and on the other, I like nice bright cards. I know my thinking on it but want to elicit other responses. Thanks in advance...

[HRBAKER]

Leon,
Since what makes these cards unique is the back, I would opt for the Holmes with the best back stamp.
Jeff

[Leon]

Originally Posted by HRBAKER

Leon,
Since what makes these cards unique is the back, I would opt for the Holmes with the best back stamp.
Jeff

That was my pick too....

[Tedw9]

I'm on the side of the HOF'er "Bobbie" Doerr. Of course it helps that I'm a big Doerr fan and love the Sox. But that aside, I will always take a HOF'er.

[GoldenAge50s]

Leon--

As long as you already HAVE both, why not keep BOTH? You have a very scarce issue to begin with & one is a nice clear image & the other is a HOFer.

I know you are a type-collector & 1 card of each is enough for your satisfaction, but in this case I would make an exception---at least for the time being.

[Rob D.]

What Jeff said.

[D. Bergin]

I might go with the HOF'er if it was a higher level guy. In this case I like the Holmes.