The Collectability of Oddballs, Variations, Fakes & Customs

[mouschi]

My memories from when I was 12 and younger are few & far between (or is it far & few between?...I'm gonna stick with the first one.) Many of my

memories are marked with things that have to do with baseball and baseball cards. Why? because ...



(Pssst....baseball cards. Baseball cards measure 2.5x3.5")

Fewer still, are the memories that don't have anything to do with baseball. One such memory is with my childhood friend David. I went with his family up into the mountains, and we went wading into the crystal clear water of a brook/river of some sort. I remember the excitement of finding neat & interesting rocks to collect. There was no thought of book value for the rocks. No concern of rival bidders trying to go for the rock that I liked. No wondering if the rocks were gradable, counterfeit or altered in any way. Just me and my friend, searching for neat looking rocks for our collections.

Whenever I pickup some cheaper variations for my collection, I'm taken back to that time. Going for a low numbered, highly sought after Canseco can be stressful and sometimes ends in disappointment if some lunatic out there is willing to pay more than I am (Hey, it has happened on occasion! I normally get my card, but not every time.)

I have been fortunate to pick up several new cards for my collection recently. Some have been of the main-stream higher dollar variety, but I'm going to focus on the pickups that I've acquired which are much more obscure. Variations / errors / odd balls that you won't find in Beckett.

GASP!

Yes, variations that are not checklisted. Allow me to invite you into a world where checklisted cards are not the only cards of value.

Enter: The Cardboard Matrix ....



I could talk about the recent 89 Score promo Mattingly that went for well over $400


Or perhaps the 1988 Star Griffey (GASP! That Star company has cards of value?!)


Or what about the '93 finest Nolan Ryan promo?


Yes, these are the exception, not the rule, as the vast majority of this stuff goes for peanuts, but my point is that the collector of 2015 has come a very long way in terms of placing value on cards. Gone are the days of collectors saying "If it isn't in the price guide, it doesn't have value." But enough about other people's cards. Let's talk about my latest additions, shall we?

Fresh off the heels of my 1991 Topps article, (check out the # of ebay listings for '91 Topps glowbacks now) I have picked up a few other variations of the 1991 Topps Canseco



First, I grabbed the pink number version. This is about as borderline as you'll see in my collection in terms of the "c'mon...is this *really* a variation?" question. I have it primarily because it is known by other 1991 Topps collectors as a legit variation.

Second, I was able to grab a bold 40th logo back version.



As for the glow cards, I picked up a smattering of 1991 Topps regular and all-stars. I was able to find the light back glow, dark back glow and no glow for the All Star. I also was able to get those for the regular Canseco ... well ... except for the no glow. Then, jacksoncoupage stepped in

and said he had one. He mentioned he'd send it to me, so that should be coming in soon - thanks!!!

This is where things get a little more interesting ... for me, anyway. I found this piece:



It is a blank back, the cards are normal size and on 1991 Topps card stock. I don't know if I've ever seen a blank back 1991 Topps card before, so I had to pounce on this. Apparently it was a promo sheet only given to people in the "MVP Program". As I wrote about previously, the regular 1991 Topps cards had about 4 million of each produced. How many of these sheets were produced? 10? 100? 1,000? Regardless of the number, the amount of blank back cards available from them are likely significantly less after 25 years of these things being destroyed. Heck, when I got this sheet, the Boggs had a heavy crease through it. With that said though, I was able to pull a perfect Rickey Henderson, Bo Jackson, Roger Clemens and Walt Weiss from it. #lovethisstuff

A while back, I saw some 1991 Topps baseball cards with football backs. I thought that would have been a cool item to have if a Canseco ever popped up. Well, I tracked down a 1991 Topps All Star Canseco with a football back. Now I need the regular front version if that exists!



I also picked up a 1991 Topps cracker jack 4 in 1 card w/Canseco on it.

A few neat cards that came in the other day were these two 1992 Topps cards:



Notice anything different on them? (Hint: something is missing on the front of them!)

And just like that, junk wax cards are exciting & fun again. Sometimes, I feel like that kid who was searching for rocks in the stream in the mountains again.

I had been looking at a particular Panini sticker card for a while that has the venezuelen stamp on the back. It is a mystery as to what they are and why they have the stamp. Was it some collector who did this, or was it Panini? The sticker is shrouded in mystery - even after my feeble attempts of researching. For me and my collection, the value is in the mystery and the potential back story. The more of the story I have, the more valuable it is to me.



Even if it is some kid that stamped them on his own, there is still collectability for player collectors, somehow. A while back, I posed the question to the collecting community: "Do you collect known counterfeits?" The answer for many, was a resounding YES. No, I'm not talking about forged autographs or butchered patch cards. I'm talking about the well known counterfeits of yesteryear. The infamous Pete Rose rookie, the 1984 Donruss Mattingly, the 1986 Donruss Canseco (Beckett reads: BEWARE OF CANSECO COUNTERFEITS).

Another card that was heavily counterfeited was the 1984 Chong's Jose Canseco. It was his second card ever made. A flimsy black and white card, where the back notes of "Sequoia Super Market" and "Biggest Little Supermarket in Town". Canseco played for the Modesto A's, and is a very well known card among his collectors. After the question was poised, fellow Canseco collector Razor asked me...

"So, do YOU have the REAL Chong or FAKE Chong?"

I never figured to check, and didn't even know what to look for, so he schooled me on the differences. Sure enough, mine was FAKE! I was fortunate to grab a REAL copy, though. If the tables were turned though and I already had the real version, rest assured I'd be looking to purchase a counterfeit version for my collection as well. Here is a pic of the two side by side. The fake is on the left, and the real one is on the right:



Which leads me to this request: If you have a counterfeit '86 Donruss Canseco or 91 Desert Storm Canseco <makes hand into a phone and puts up to face> Call me.

If you were ever into odd-ball cards in the 80's/90's, you knew that Canseco had 2 cards with Madonna. One was rather promiscuous looking, and the other was more of a cartoon. While I have both of them, I ran across a promo 4 in 1 card of the cartoon version that I had never seen before, so I grabbed it:



GOLD!

One of the let downs was an oddball card of "JOE" Canseco. This oddball (along with one other, I think) had card shops and collectors talking, because it was either an error, or they were trying to Americanize the Cuban slugger. I found one on ebay, and while I had it already, I noticed it had a much brighter border than mine. I took a picture of mine and compared it to the one for sale, then sent to the seller to ask if his truly represented the color on the screen. (His on the left, mine on the right).



He said yes, so I took a chance. It came in yesterday aaaandddd....same border color :/ Oh well - I had to give it a try!

I picked up this other prototype that I TOTALLY whiffed on. It was on ebay, I didn't see it until it was too late. Fortunately, the seller said he had a few ... as in ... only 3 or 4 were made! 1996 Leaf Steel Proof:



Upon more investigation, here is the back story: His company made them for Leaf. The tooling was destroyed after they went bankrupt and these were used as early tests for the process. Only about 15 players in the set have these proofs made.

The final card I'd like to mention in my collection is something that doesn't quite fit in with the others above. I received this card for free along with a note:



Thanks again Patrick! That was incredibly nice of you.

This doesn't fit in with ANYTHING I'm saying, but I thought they were clever enough to whip up and post. Does anyone else feel this way?



Or perhaps more suitable ....
(continued....)

[mouschi]

Last but not least, I thought I'd show off a few extra customs. Why? Because if you are as sick as I am, you know that the card companies simply aren't making enough variations (ha!)

I present to you some 1976 Topps Yankees legends:



and 1976 Topps ....



Finally, some Chipper Jones love in NNOF, Superfractor and Wax Box bottom form:



Worry not, folks - the backs of my work mention they are not "real" just in case they do slip into the wrong hands at some point down the road
One last thing: Last week, I was picked up as a freelance writer / columnist for Sports Collectors Daily! My first article has been published about finding good local deals and flipping them. Check it out! Who knows? You might just see some more articles of mine in other outlets in the future

Anyway, that about does it for this article. I hope to hear from you about your cool odd ball / variation / error finds. More importantly, I hope to hear about your Canseco stuff that I don't have!

[ullmandds]

i like the rock finding analogy...i love looking for cool rocks!!!!

[brian1961]

I would like to chime in with regard to the niche of custom cards, otherwise known as fantasy cards. Succinctly put, I love them. They will likely never rise in value; nevertheless, the emotional and visual reward they have given me has been well worth the time and effort I put into crafting them. Some of them I have made with hired help. It was very costly. Be that as it may, the end result was stunning and utter joy to me, and, truth be told---unusually fulfilling. The latter I'm referring to were done in conjunction with my book on postwar regional / food issues, NEVER CHEAPER BY THE DOZEN. With the vital assistance of a computer graphic artist, I lovingly created fantasy 1954 Wilson Franks cards of Mickey Mantle and Jackie Robinson. I absolutely love them. Naturally, I had printed on the backsides, in an innocuous spot, the year they were printed.


Must go. Fantasy cards complement my vintage card collection nicely, what's left of it.

Kind regards, Brian Powell