Are These Autographs Legitimate? (Jodi Birkholm's Quick Opinion is in Post #14)

[leftygrove10]

Please take a look at the card in the scan below. Any opinions as to the authenticity of these autographs?

IMO, the Grove auto looks good, but then again, I can probably make a decent replica in about 15 minutes... So someone else could have done the same thing....

Also, IMO, if one of these autos is legit, then (more than likely) they are all legit...

Any recommendations on which company to send this card to if I choose to get it authenticated? I am not a member of PSA, nor do I want to be forced to send 5 cards in just to get this 1 authenticated...

[old13man]

The Cochrane auto doesn't look right to me. It doesn't seem to match up to the ones I have seen before.

[mr2686]

The Cochrane doesn't look right to me either. I've seen maybe 30 to 40 authenticated Cochranes, including a couple of documents, and his signature never looked that neat.

[Scott Garner]

I will only comment on the Lefty Grove autograph, but it looks right on to me based on my exemplars.

[perezfan]

I think they all look a bit off... just my opinion

[Piedmont Sport]

I'd let Jimmy Spence review - of all the places to get an opinion Jimmy will give you an honset answer. I know this site is chock full of experts - if your unsure - give it to a 3rd party and pay the fee - While some would disagree it's become popular to bash JSA and PSA/DNA - can anyone say they never make a mistake - or willing to put themselves on the line and prepare an LOA and stand by it and become successful. Just my thought