1961 Golden Press grading

[rdwyer]

What is the grading criteria for punched out cards? How would you grade these cards? Are there any 8's, 9's or 10's? Which one should I get graded? TIA

[swarmee]

Cards are too far away to tell, but the basics of grading apply:
1) Perforations have to be torn without leaving creases.
2) No surface imperfections (scratches, print defects)
3) Centered properly
4) Should present cleanly (aka only minor toning) if you're looking for NM-MT or better.
5) Look at PSA's website for their Auction Prices Realized and search for the recent sale values of each of the cards. Or check their Registry to see if collectors are actually fighting over cards to improve their sets.

Also, this should be in the post-war forum.

[rdwyer]

swarmee: Thanks for the help. It helped a lot! Leon: Please move to Post war, as I screwed up.

[Yastrzemski Sports]

Agreed on all points mentioned above.

The cards cannot be cut out with scissors or a razor. They have to be torn out by hand. If they are cut and don’t have the perforations they won’t be graded.

The keys to the set are the first 3 and last 6. Those were on the outside of the book and usually have surface wear.

A lot of these are not worth much in an 8 or 9 so be picky. I agree that the photos are way too small to see details. Good luck.

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by Yastrzemski Sports

The keys to the set are the first 3 and last 6. Those were on the outside of the book and usually have surface wear.

A lot of these are not worth much in an 8 or 9 so be picky.

IMO don't bother with any cards inside except for really crisp clean first tier HOFers: Cobb, Gehrig, DiMaggio, etc. 6-7-8 cards of the others won't sell for the price of grading. Check the outside cards closely because they frequently have surface scuffs that will just kill your value.

[rdwyer]

Lots of great advice. Thanks!

[Snapolit1]

Originally Posted by Yastrzemski Sports

Agreed on all points mentioned above.

The cards cannot be cut out with scissors or a razor. They have to be torn out by hand. If they are cut and don’t have the perforations they won’t be graded.

The keys to the set are the first 3 and last 6. Those were on the outside of the book and usually have surface wear.

A lot of these are not worth much in an 8 or 9 so be picky. I agree that the photos are way too small to see details. Good luck.

Interesting. Can't cut out with scissors. Such random stuff in the world of grading. Who really cares how precisely it was removed from the book. What if the book publisher said "remove carefully with scissors". Weirdness if you ask me.

[tedzan]

The prices and the grading is all over the place on these cards.

A Gehrig on ebay for $325 vs. another for $20.....with no discernable difference in their grading. I could provide many more such examples.

My advice is purchase the album (relatively inexpensive), and enjoy these cards as they were meant to be enjoyed.





TED Z

T206 Reference
.

[commishbob]

Originally Posted by tedzan

The prices and the grading is all over the place on these cards.

A Gehrig on ebay for $325 vs. another for $20.....with no discernable difference in their grading. I could provide many more such examples.

My advice is purchase the album (relatively inexpensive), and enjoy these cards as they were meant to be enjoyed.


TED Z

T206 Reference
.

Solid advice that we can all stand to be reminded of from time to time.

[swarmee]

Originally Posted by Snapolit1

Who really cares how precisely it was removed from the book. What if the book publisher said "remove carefully with scissors". Weirdness if you ask me.

How is it random? The cards are perforated, as in intentionally intended to be torn out. Same rules for any perforated cards. If they were not perforated and had borders, they should be cut on the outside of those borders, or they'd be considered Altered-Trimmed. If you take a perforated card and trim off the edges so they're straight, you've altered the cards by trimming.

[JoeDfan]

Just so I understand, is it ok to cut them out with scissors as long as you leave the tiny perforations attached?
Or no? Will that not get a grade?
Or is that not even possible?