Are these real?

[Deertick]

I already have my opinion, but I may have an auctioneer check out other opinions.
Includes an Ali, Ford, Koufax, Joe D, and Teddy

http://www.auctionzip.com/aflive.htm...C&wa=autograph

[shelly]

I saw a lot of Florida on that site. Real or not I would stay away

[RichardSimon]

The photos of the items are so good and so clear how could you not feel confident about biddiing in this auction?

[Wymers Auction]

I think I might be bidding on the Pet Rose autographed baseball. Jim I know that you are aware these are fake. I saw like Shelly many from the Sunshine state and that is no compliment. I saw a Milkey Mantle fake. The fake where Mantle and Ford are signing has been discussed everywhere. From there I think we apply the Jim Stinson Pee Rule and we come to the conclusion that most are fake if not all of them. A really bad consignor at the least.

[Deertick]

Originally Posted by Wymers Auction

I think I might be bidding on the Pet Rose autographed baseball. Jim I know that you are aware these are fake. I saw like Shelly many from the Sunshine state and that is no compliment. I saw a Milkey Mantle fake. The fake where Mantle and Ford are signing has been discussed everywhere. From there I think we apply the Jim Stinson Pee Rule and we come to the conclusion that most are fake if not all of them. A really bad consignor at the least.

I told them the baseball items and the Ali were bad. Also a "Saving Private Ryan" script signed by Spielberg and Hanks. I wasn't sure about the NASCAR, but I applied the Stinson Rule. I have since checked several and they are equally horrid.

I just checked and this is the 2nd time I have contacted them. HOWEVER, the last time I missed their reply. It basically said they don't put much stock in anonymous email and for me to call them. ( I had forgot to include my contact info). So I put this latest batch more on me than them. It is too late for this auction now, but I will call them next week.

[Deertick]

Aaron went for $100, Ali $85, Mays $75, all others (Mantle,Ford,Williams, etc) between $20-$36. Sounds like 3 collectors duped and the rest coming to a flea market near you.
Oh, and the signed script? $30

[jgmp123]

Originally Posted by Deertick

Aaeon went for $100, Ali $85, Mays $75, all others (Mantle,Ford,Williams, etc) between $20-$36. Sounds like 3 collectors duped and the rest coming to a flea market near you.
Oh, and the signed script? $30

And with no policing, now they go straight to eBay....