Input needed on a developing ebay buyer situation

[hcv123]

Originally Posted by Empty77

Fair inverse; probably I was subconsciously assuming Howard wouldn't have sold off his good one and have kept a crappier one for himself!

I have both a PSA 8 and an even nicer BVG 8!

[Empty77]

Originally Posted by hcv123

I have both a PSA 8 and an even nicer BVG 8!

Sooo, might your nicer BVG 8 then be a PSA 9, or just 8.5??

[Batpig]

The 7 from the auction looks pretty dang nice. You didn’t by any chance crack it and resub for the 8 you now own, did you?

[Empty77]

Originally Posted by Batpig

The 7 from the auction looks pretty dang nice. You didn’t by any chance crack it and resub for the 8 you now own, did you?

Aha! The theory is further refined!

[Marchillo]

Sell the holder not the card :/

I agree that maybe you cracked it out and resubbed it and it’s sitting in another holder. Compare the images in your listing to the others in your collection.

[hcv123]

but, HIGHLY unlikely I cracked and resubbed - I very rarely do that. I think one of the 2 possibilities mentioned here is likely - 1 - it is somewhere here waiting to be found or 2 - I accidentally shipped it as a different card somewhere in the past.
As far as the BVG 8 - the way PSA is grading these days I would offer an educated guess that it would come back between a PSA 1 and a PSA 9. So sick of the subjective inconsistency. Seems like they highest grade they give to mint bazooka boxes these days is a PSA 5!

[Rose4HOF]

I had a PSA 8 on eBay and added a PSA 7 of the same card many months later. With so many cards posted, I forgot I had 2 on at the same time. Guy bought the PSA 7 and I shipped him the PSA 8 by accident. I didnt realize until somebody bought the PSA 8 and all I could find was the PSA 7. I try not to make mistakes often but when I do, they get cleaned up quick. I emailed the buyer and explained what happened, refunded his payment and sent him the tracking number for the free PSA 7. It was a costly hit but shit happens and I solved it instantly and put it behind me.