Top 30 - T206 HOF List

[tmw2ward]

Guys,

Please see my attempt at putting together the top 30 HOFers in order. I did not account for back type or any type of variations. Thoughts?

Tim

Top 30 - T206 Hall of Fame Set

1 Wagner, Honus
2 Plank, Eddie
3 Cobb, Ty - Green
4 Cobb, Ty - Red
5 Cobb, Ty - Bat On Shoulder
6 Cobb, Ty - Bat Off Shoulder
7 Johnson, Walter - Portrait
8 Young, Cy - Portrait
9 Mathewson, Christy - Portrait
10 Young, Cy - Glove Showing
11 Johnson, Walter - Hands at Chest
12 Young, Cy - Bare Hand Showing
13 Lajoie, Nap - Portrait
14 Speaker, Tris
15 Mathewson, Christy - White Cap
16 Mathewson, Christy - Dark Cap
17 Lajoie, Nap - Batting
18 Lajoie, Nap - Throwing
19 Collins, Eddie
20 Brown, Mordecai - Portrait
21 Chance, Frank - Red Back
22 Evers, Johnny - Portrait
23 Tinker, Joe - Portrait
24 Keeler, Willie - Portrait
25 Evers, Johnny - Cub Shirt
26 Brown, Mordecai - Cub Shirt
27 Joss, Addie - Portrait
28 Walsh, Ed
29 Keeler, Willie - Bat
30 Baker, Home Run

[The Nasty Nati]

I would rearrange a few assuming your list is based solely on current value.

I think a few of these players/poses like Lajoie Portrait and Eddie Collins should increase in value and ranking as the years go by. I can see the Lajoie Portrait surpass the 2 Cy Young action poses and Eddie Collins make it's way up wedged between the Christy White and Dark cap.

1. Wagner, Honus
2. Plank, Eddie
3. Cobb, Ty - Green
4. Cobb, Ty - Red
5. Cobb, Ty - Bat On Shoulder
6. Cobb, Ty - Bat Off Shoulder
7. Johnson, Walter - Portrait
8. Young, Cy - Portrait
9. Mathewson, Christy - Portrait
10. Johnson, Walter - Hands at Chest
11. Young, Cy - Glove Showing
12. Young, Cy - Bare Hand Showing
13. Speaker, Tris
14. Lajoie, Nap - Portrait
15. Mathewson, Christy - White Cap
16. Mathewson, Christy - Dark Cap
17. Lajoie, Nap – Batting
18. Lajoie, Nap - Throwing
19. Keeler, Willie – Portrait
20. Tinker, Joe – Portrait
21. Evers, Johnny - Portrait
22. Collins, Eddie
23. Brown, Mordecai - Portrait
24. Chance, Frank - Red Back
25. Evers, Johnny - Cub Shirt
26. Keeler- Bat
27. Brown, Mordecai - Cub Shirt
28. Joss, Addie - Portrait
29. Walsh, Ed
30. Baker, Home Run

[wolf441]

I like the list. I think I'd put Waddell portrait at #30 over Baker, but I'm partial to the portraits and love some of the stories about Waddell.

[mrvster]

good attempt

[Rhotchkiss]

This is a decent list, and I think its generally accurate as far as HOFers go. But, I think limiting your list to HOFers ignores 3 of the best/most important T206s cards -- Magie error, and O'Hara and Demmitt PB.

[Sean]

The Evers Cubs Shirt (Blue Sky) is easily the most valuable Cub on the list, and should probably rank somewhere around #11.

[tmw2ward]

Thanks!

[rats60]

1 Wagner, Honus
2 Plank, Eddie
3 Cobb, Ty - Green
4 Cobb, Ty - Bat On Shoulder
5 Cobb, Ty - Red
6 Cobb, Ty - Bat Off Shoulder
7 Young, Cy - Portrait
8 Johnson, Walter - Portrait
9 Mathewson, Christy - Portrait
10 Young, Cy - Bare Hand Showing
11 Mathewson, Christy - White Cap
12 Young, Cy - Glove Showing
13 Johnson, Walter - Hands at Chest
14 Speaker, Tris
15 Mathewson, Christy - Dark Cap
16 Lajoie, Nap - Portrait
17 Tinker, Joe - Portrait
18 Keeler, Willie - Portrait
19 Tinker, Joe - Hands on Knees
20 Lajoie, Nap - Batting
21 Lajoie, Nap - Throwing
22 Keeler, Willie - Bat
23 Evers, Johnny - Portrait
24 Chance, Frank - Yellow Back
25 Evers, Johnny - Cub Shirt
26 McGraw, John - No Cap
27 Marquard, Rube - Portrait
28 Brown, Mordecai - Cub Shirt
29 Chance, Frank - Red Back
30 Collins, Eddie

[RiceBondsMntna2Young]

edit: I found a ranking of scarcity of back. Lenox -Brown is one thing but how closely does back rarity track demand in general? Especially since VCP combine the entire categories of Piedmont and Sweet Caporal into one?

For the Mathewsons, does it matter which back variation? If so, is there a ranking for back variations on the Portrait, White Cap, and Dark Cap?