New pick up thread debate and other board issues?

Leon · #1 05-08-2009, 09:06 AM

So we have been on the new site a week and there are a few more things on the agenda to talk about, since most of the registrations have taken place (though there are still 5-10 a day coming in). The other admin/mods and myself have been talking about the monthly pick up threads and questioning whether we need to start a new one anymore, more than 1 time a month? So that is the first question. What is everyone's thoughts on that subject?
Then we can also open it up to any other things on ya'lls minds. Questions, concerns, suggestions etc......It's everyone's forum so here is your chance to say something if it's on your mind. It looks like only a few regulars didn't make the transition yet but I have to say, if they don't come over because this new forum is too difficult then I think they are just finding something to be upset about. Overall I am very happy with the way it's gone....Thanks for everyone's patience so far and thanks too for the huge amount of emails I have received that are thanful in nature...I might not have responded to every one as I have had around 2000 emails in the last week but know that your kind words are appreciated very much.

canjond · #2 05-08-2009, 09:13 AM

Leon - I agree... no need for new pickup threads in the same month. The reason we had multiple pickup threads in the same month on the old baord was because of load times and scrolling. With the new board, since only 10 posts appear on a page - there isn't the load time or scrolling issues.

T206Collector · #3 05-08-2009, 09:14 AM

Absolutely the right way to go. You can always catch up to where you last left off. A lot more cards will get seen this way.

Leon · #4 05-08-2009, 09:36 AM

Please remember that you can change the number of posts that you see in a thread, via your user control panel (user cp) to any amount up to 40. I have mine set at 40, changed from the default of 10, and it helped me a lot......thanks for the feedback so far....

RichR · #5 05-08-2009, 09:43 AM

Leon, Thanks for that info, I didn't realize you could change the number of posts seen!

Doug · #6 05-08-2009, 09:50 AM

I like having them all in one place. It makes it easier to see them all.

barrysloate · #7 05-08-2009, 10:43 AM

The new board has been pleasantly easy to use, compared with the issues we were having the first time around. I'm even beginning to like it.

jim · #8 05-08-2009, 10:57 AM

Everything works well for me. One pick-up a month thread is fine.

canjond · #9 05-08-2009, 10:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leon

Please remember that you can change the number of posts that you see in a thread, via your user control panel (user cp) to any amount up to 40. I have mine set at 40, changed from the default of 10, and it helped me a lot......thanks for the feedback so far....

Thanks for pointing that out, Leon. I actually forgot that. However, I think this also helps make my point. If certain members do not like to scroll through 40 posts of pick-ups per page, they can simply change the default back down to 10. I think having monthly pick-ups all listed in the same thread is the best way to go. Less clutter that way, too!

Jacklitsch · #10 05-08-2009, 11:18 AM

I agree. One pickup thread a month.

Definitely set your posts per page default to 40. Makes life a lot easier.

My only complaint, well maybe two: I sure miss the page down feature and second not enough smilies.

EDIT: I do however see a tab for "View First Unread". That, in effect, has a page down function.

buymycards · #11 05-08-2009, 11:21 AM

There isn't a need to scroll through all of the old threads. You can set this up so the newest threads are on top.

Rick

T206Collector · #12 05-08-2009, 01:48 PM

...if someone goes back and edits an old post, will it show up as a new "blue arrow down"? I assume not.

Leon · #13 05-08-2009, 03:34 PM

I don't think an edit makes a post into a "new" blue highlighted post. (not sure if that was your question) It will always show an edit by anyone and a deleted post will always show a "deleted post" wording...and who deleted it. Hope this helps.

DixieBaseball · #14 05-08-2009, 04:04 PM

1 Pickup Thread per month seems like the best idea.

I like seeing all the cards together whether it be the first half of the month or the second half... Will be easier to go back as well to only look at 12 Threads for the year to see the pickups for that month. Good idea, better way to track the progress of our collecting.

You could even start archiving each thread, May Pick Up Thread, June Pick up Thread, etc...

I think it would be cool to go back over the years and review what folks were picking up, etc...

2 cents -

jmk59 · #15 05-08-2009, 05:11 PM

I think the new board is great, and one pick up thread is fine, but I think we have really lost something in the image area.

I know I know I know - the image hosting with it's one-week self destruct mechanism was a pain in the rear. But the bottom line is that you could post a full size image without using an outside image hosting site like photobucket or whatever.

I am thinking that some response to this comment will be along the lines of trying to push and badger people to get on photobucket or whatever. But let the numbers speak for themselves:

There are 80 posts that include scans in the combined pick-up threads for May, REA, Legendary and Goodwin. Of the 80 posts with scans, 18 of them are thumbnails. That's about 22.5% folks.

I think that a "failure" rate that high for posting full-size images basically says that telling people to use photobucket is an incomplete answer and is being shown not to work.

And there is also a loss in reading the threads - you used to be able to flip down and watch all the pictures go by. Now you miss about 1/4 of them unless you stop to click, and if there is more than one thumbnail you also have to click through each one once it's open.

So ... is there something that can be done to allow posting of full-size images directly without either using photobucket or standing on your head up in the User CP album area? Not to mention any other boards, but one of them has an incredibly easy boop-boop-done way to put a full picture right in a thread in about two seconds, and not from photobucket.

Thx much.

J

And ... in those four pick-up threads with the 80 posts that included pictures? There were a total of ~178 posts that had no picture at all. The commentary outnumbers the actual scans by more than 2-1.

And ... I know the numbers probably don't add up. It was a quick count. Don't email me.

Rob D. · #16 05-08-2009, 08:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jmk59

It was a quick count. Don't email me.

OK, Barry.

(Not even for advise *sic*?)

Leon · #17 05-09-2009, 01:05 AM

I can look into that photo uploading issue but not sure if there is a work around. I know it's a hassle too as I have to use my other web hosting account to upload pictures in order for them to be full size here. I will get an answer but not sure it's the one we'll like.....best regards