T206 Magie (PSA 1) on eBay altered?

[atx840]

I think this is the same card. Thoughts?

Crease near the ear, through the hairline and the "P" line up but look to have been colored in.

Scans didnt quite line up so card shifts a bit on the lower corners

[perezfan]

Of course it's the same card. Just look at the evidence.... not to mention the authenticator and the seller.

Good catch!

[MVSNYC]

Chris, fantastic catch. I was bidding...definitely not anymore.

How did it get into another PSA holder after being doctored? Ridiculous.

Thanks!

[buymycards]

And once again, PSA doesn't catch it.

[perezfan]

The bidding has exceeded $4,500 and is clearly altered. Anytime you see that corrupt PWCC sticker, you know it's altered.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/22447109116...IAAOSwyhpgqbyt

[rand1com]

How about a picture of the back on the first card for comparison purposes?

[Papa Stephano]

As a person returning to the hobby after 20+ years away, I'm disgusted by what I've read about PSA.

I haven't read much about SGC. Is there anything out there indicating the same issues as PSA?

[Casey2296]

PWCC went full Keyser Sosay on the blemishes but that border crease just below his left shoulder clinches it for me.

[atx840]

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by perezfan

The bidding has exceeded $4,500 and is clearly altered. Anytime you see that corrupt PWCC sticker, you know it's altered.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/22447109116...IAAOSwyhpgqbyt

Now now, Betsy told us two years ago that Brent has no idea whose cards he is reviewing when he gives out the stickers.

[steve B]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

Now now, Betsy told us two years ago that Brent has no idea whose cards he is reviewing when he gives out the stickers.

Well, it probably is hard remembering exactly who altered what....