Kaline Opinions

[39special]

I got this Kaline yesterday TTM and I'm not sure if he signed it.I have a ball
signed by him and the signatures don't look the same.Wanted to see what
some other opinions were.

[Mr. Zipper]

I've seen other reports of Kaline signatures like this of late. Very rushed and careless.

I think it's probably real, and the key takeaway is: Al is getting tired of signing.

[39special]

Thanks Steve.I'm sure he gets alot of requests.His signature has really changed!

[chaddurbin]

yes he's gotten lazy. more like ai instead of al now.

[isaac2004]

Crap I sent a TTM to him last week, how much money did you send?

[39special]

Originally Posted by isaac2004

Crap I sent a TTM to him last week, how much money did you send?

$10

[jimjim]

This is how he has been signing for a while now. If you include $10, then this is more than likely the autograph you are going to get back. I guess he thinks his autograph is worth more and won't give you the show sig unless you pony up the money.

[shelly]

I know you are going to be upset. You send a player in the Hall of Fame. ten dollars and you think he signs poorly. What does it cost for a player who won rookie of the year? $100 or more. You pay a person that played one year that kind of money and You are upset because for ten dollars this is who the man is that you are paying ten dollars to and he signs it . What do you think you would get from the stars of today? This is his record match it to any of players today.
18× All-Star (1955, 1956, 1957, 1958, 1959, 1959², 1960, 1960², 1961, 1961², 1962², 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967, 1971, 1974)
World Series champion (1968)
10× Gold Glove Award winner (1957, 1958, 1959, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967)
1955 AL batting title
1973 Roberto Clemente Award
1969 Hutch Award
1968 Lou Gehrig Memorial Award
Detroit Tigers #6 retired.

I really am insulted for your lack of respect.

[39special]

[QUOTE=shelly;1084248]I know you are going to be upset. You send a player in the Hall of Fame. ten dollars and you think he signs poorly. What does it cost for a player who won rookie of the year? $100 or more. You pay a person that played one year that kind of money and You are upset because for ten dollars this is who the man is that you are paying ten dollars to and he signs it . What do you think you would get from the stars of today? This is his record match it to any of players today.
18× All-Star (1955, 1956, 1957, 1958, 1959, 1959², 1960, 1960², 1961, 1961², 1962², 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967, 1971, 1974)
World Series champion (1968)
10× Gold Glove Award winner (1957, 1958, 1959, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967)
1955 AL batting title
1973 Roberto Clemente Award
1969 Hutch Award
1968 Lou Gehrig Memorial Award
Detroit Tigers #6 retired.

I really am ashamed.[/QUOTE

All I asked for was opinions if this was his signature.I wasn't complaining about a sloppy signature.I'm not upset at all!!

[shelly]

It had nothing to do with you. Look at the comments after.
Big Dave,drw11, jason, clutch and ATP. Do you agree or disagree?

,

[39special]

Originally Posted by shelly

It had nothing to do with you. Look at the comments below.

Sorry Shelly

[campyfan39]

The sig is good IMO.
Mr. Kaline is one of the best TTM'ers around.
He typically signs for $5
I don't think anyone was disparaging Al
**ducks**

[shelly]

No problem, you had nothing to do with who I was giving a reply to.

[isaac2004]

Originally Posted by shelly

It had nothing to do with you. Look at the comments after.
Big Dave,drw11, jason, clutch and ATP. Do you agree or disagree?

,

I am super happy he signs at all. If i can get his autograph and the money goes to him and not some ebay chump, its a win win

[chaddurbin]

i'm fine with the sig myself, can't beat it for $10. better than paying 4x-10x for contemporary hof'ers during his time.

[shelly]

Originally Posted by campyfan39

The sig is good IMO.
Mr. Kaline is one of the best TTM'ers around.
He typically signs for $5
I don't think anyone was disparaging Al
**ducks**

Ok then you and I differ. These are the comments that bothered me.
yes he's gotten lazy. more like ai instead of al now.
Crap I sent a TTM to him last week, how much money did you send?
This is how he has been signing for a while now. If you include $10, then this is more than likely the autograph you are going to get back. I guess he thinks his autograph is worth more and won't give you the show sig unless you pony up the money.
I guess these remarks are not insulting. If they where sent to his agent or even to him. Would you think this was a complement or not a little bit insulting?

[Duluth Eskimo]

Originally Posted by shelly

It had nothing to do with you. Look at the comments after.
Big Dave,drw11, jason, clutch and ATP. Do you agree or disagree?

,

Maybe some day I'll be a big shot and judge other people and their items like some I know. It reminds of something my father taught me a long time ago, "That this is what's great about America. Every idiot has the right to his own opinion".

[shelly]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

Maybe some day I'll be a big shot and judge other people and their items like some I know. It reminds of something my father taught me a long time ago, "That this is what's great about America. Every idiot has the right to his own opinion".

And I respect yours.

[Bosox Blair]

As this older Kaline sig shows, the older auto is definitely more distinct/legible, but the "l" in Al was smallish back then too:

[clutch]

Originally Posted by shelly

It had nothing to do with you. Look at the comments after.
Big Dave,drw11, jason, clutch and ATP. Do you agree or disagree?

,

If you are asking if I think you took yet another thread and turned it into something completely negative, then my answer is yes.

As far as Mr. Kaline's signature...

I have noticed that the quality of his signature has been in the decline. Let's also keep in mind that this man is 78 years old. He probably has gotten tired of autograph requests after so many years. I've heard many stories of him being a little grumpy when asked for his autograph, but he always obliges. I was born and raised in Michigan and have been a die hard Tiger fan my entire life. Mr. Kaline has always been a class act and has made himself available to the community. I have many of his autographs in my collection obtained both personally and through the mail and never had a negative experience.

I'm giving my opinion because I was asked for it. I personally wasn't offended by any comments on this thread. You are all grown adults and can say whatever you want.

[39special]

I want to thank everyone for there opinions.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by 39special

I want to thank everyone for there opinions.

it probably could have waited till like 5am or something?