Mickey Mantle and Stan Musial Feedback

[Oldsaybrook21]

I need to get some feedback for a good friend of mine who got Stan's auto through internet 2 years ago.

I know Stan's signature has changed over the past few years which I’m not familiar with

This looks much different than the ones I’ve seen in his early years, so we wanted to get some feedback on piece,

Thanks everyone

[IMG]http://www.net54baseball.com/picture.php?albumid=289&pictureid=5361


Mickey was obtain 50 years ago from a friend,, friend, friend, over 50 years ago down in Spring Training. I do think this looks real good but more more opinions please

http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=5362

[Oldsaybrook21]

http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=5361

[mr2686]

Here's one I got from Stan approx 2 years ago for your comparison.

[Oldsaybrook21]

Good Morning,

Could I get some more feedback on these 2 autographs?

I could use your help and expertise, thanks everyone

[doug.goodman]

Hi -

You say that a friend got the Mantle at spring training over 50 years ago. If I was you, I would take the word of your friend and enjoy your Mantle autograph, and the thought of your friend meeting him on a sunny spring day.

Do you really want to take the opinion (and that's all it would be) of those of us who may be experts, but who you do not know, over the word of your friend? It's not like you could sell that scrap of paper and buy a new house. Maybe a nice dinner.

As for the Musial, "over the internet" covers a lot of area. Was it from Stan's company, or was it from a purveyor of fine (possibly) forged autographs such as Coaches Corner, or from some place in the middle of the "potentially real scale"?

Enjoy what you have,
Doug

[Oldsaybrook21]

So true, thanks Doug for the post.

We're trading and I would love add any real Mickey into collection even its paper or cut out, it will look nice in my office.

BTW I found out from a my friend after he searched his paypal account that he purchased the Stan Auto from Atomicsports back in 2009 & we got some feedback the dealer is very rebutable (tommy orr)


Happy Holidays, thank you