1927 Murderers Row Photo

[mschwade]

In the upcoming Grey Flannel auction, there is a 1927 "Murderers Row" signed photo (see below). But if you look closely at it, Bob Meusel and Joe Dugan are not pictured and are replaced by Ben Paschal and Ray Morehart, respectively.

1) At some point in that season, was that the "Murderers Row" lineup? I would have to assume so since it appears everyone else is standing in the correct order.

2) Has anyone seen a similar photograph (not autographed) with Meusel and Dugan instead of the other two?



Thanks!
Matt

[Duluth Eskimo]

I don't know enough about the line up change, but I am wondering what other people think about the signatures. This item smells funny to me. At first glance it looks good, but the closer I look it just doesn't seem right. I am interested in the line up question as well so I'm not trying to steal your thread. If you think so I will post my question in the autograph side. Jason

[mschwade]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

I don't know enough about the line up change, but I am wondering what other people think about the signatures. This item smells funny to me. At first glance it looks good, but the closer I look it just doesn't seem right. I am interested in the line up question as well so I'm not trying to steal your thread. If you think so I will post my question in the autograph side. Jason

I don't like the Collins, that's the only one I'm comfortable enough giving an opinion.

[johnmh71]

Besides the fact that at least 4 of those guys died in the 1940's, the Urban Shocker should raise eyebrows considering that he died in 1928. That alone would make me want to become a Yankee autograph expert before I bid on this.