To slab or not to slab?

[Archive]

Posted By: Bob S

Hi Folks.

I've been around the hobby for more years than I'd like to remember, and I remember reading many posts here on VBC and elsewhere regarding this issue.

I just now tried to search for relevant posts, but after trying many word search combos, I couldn't come up with much.

So I'll risk asking the experts once again...simply put, is slabbing a good or bad idea, or does it depend on the particular circumstances?

I've also noticed quite a few posts about "crossing over" from one grader to another. With such a wide range of opinion as to grader consistency, basis of standards, etc, I wonder in what sort of circumstances this "crossing over" makes sense.

I'm sure that this has been kicked around so much, that some members will be irritated that someone brought it up again.

But if there are some of you patient enough to reiterate your opinions, I'd be very grateful.

Also, as a corrolary question, has your opinion regarding these issues changed over time, as the grading "landscape" has evolved.

Thanks.

Bob S