Jeter SP Foil auction

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by WillBBC

According to PSA only five of these have hit public auctions since 2012--out of 10,000 graded. That's pretty damn rare.

On top of that--and I know people say Jeter is overrated, yada yada--he was the face of the Yankees for almost 20 years. The demand will always be crazy high for his stuff. Throw PWCC in the mix and bam, 99K. I hope the sale actually goes through.

Many more than that according to VCP.


5/6/17 Memory Lane Image 37 $54,576.00
12/11/16 eBay Image pristinecomics r***g Best Offer $38,000.00
11/13/16 eBay Image pwcc_auctions m***s 49 $37,600.00
5/5/16 eBay Image krissy1371 n***d BIN $31,000.00
2/21/15 eBay Image heritageliveauctions o***a 3 $30,000.00
2/21/15 Heritage Image 13 $35,850.00
12/22/13 eBay Image mnmiracle2004 w***4 Best Offer $32,500.00
12/20/13 Memory Lane Image 12 $33,842.40
6/15/13 eBay Image mnmiracle2004 n***s Best Offer $36,500.00
5/20/12 SCP Auctions Image 20 $24,450.00
1/28/11 eBay Image desirableitems l***0 BIN $19,999.00

[jfkheat]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

Many more than that according to VCP.


5/6/17 Memory Lane Image 37 $54,576.00
12/11/16 eBay Image pristinecomics r***g Best Offer $38,000.00
11/13/16 eBay Image pwcc_auctions m***s 49 $37,600.00
5/5/16 eBay Image krissy1371 n***d BIN $31,000.00
2/21/15 eBay Image heritageliveauctions o***a 3 $30,000.00
2/21/15 Heritage Image 13 $35,850.00
12/22/13 eBay Image mnmiracle2004 w***4 Best Offer $32,500.00
12/20/13 Memory Lane Image 12 $33,842.40
6/15/13 eBay Image mnmiracle2004 n***s Best Offer $36,500.00
5/20/12 SCP Auctions Image 20 $24,450.00
1/28/11 eBay Image desirableitems l***0 BIN $19,999.00

How many of those were the same card selling multiple times?

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by jfkheat

How many of those were the same card selling multiple times?

What difference would that make unless a sale did not actually go through?

[jfkheat]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

What difference would that make unless a sale did not actually go through?

Because WillBBC said that only five of these have hit public auctions since 2012. He didn't say that there have only been five auctions of these cards since 2012. I didn't check VCP to see if any were sold more than one time

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by jfkheat

Because WillBBC said that only five of these have hit public auctions since 2012. He didn't say that there have only been five auctions of these cards since 2012. I didn't check VCP to see if any were sold more than one time

What's relevant is the number of auctions, no? PSA just missed some that's all. Even of their 5, 2 are the same card.

https://www.psacard.com/cardfacts/ba...oil-279/41001/

[Bored5000]

I never really followed the prices of this card until I saw this thread that it is suddenly a $100,000 card in PSA 10. Like Peter, I don't really "get" the PSA 10 thing.

The card is $100,000 in PSA 10 and less than $300 in PSA 8. On the same night PWCC auctioned off the PSA 10, PWCC auctioned off two PSA 8s and they sold for $260.55 and $276.02.

Most of my collection is stuff outside the big four sports, but I think I would be satisfied buying an "8" for $300 and using the other $99,000 for Ruth, Cobb and Wagner cards that are actually rare.

[Peter_Spaeth]

To me, if by taking it out of the holder you destroy 90 percent or more of its value -- meaning that 90 percent or more of its value is in the flip -- it makes no sense. And I think that's a fair assumption in this case, nobody (unless they had some real in with PSA) is going to pay even 10K for a raw Jeter I don't think.

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by Bored5000

I never really followed the prices of this card until I saw this thread that it is suddenly a $100,000 card in PSA 10. Like Peter, I don't really "get" the PSA 10 thing.

The card is $100,000 in PSA 10 and less than $300 in PSA 8. On the same night PWCC auctioned off the PSA 10, PWCC auctioned off two PSA 8s and they sold for $260.55 and $276.02.

Most of my collection is stuff outside the big four sports, but I think I would be satisfied buying an "8" for $300 and using the other $99,000 for Ruth, Cobb and Wagner cards that are actually rare.

Mr. Trebek, I'll take a 7 and a Maserati for $100,000.