Informal Hall of Fame Opinion Poll

[quinnsryche]

Just for fun, in YOUR opinion, if you could remove ONE PLAYER (player only) from The Baseball Hall of Fame and replace him with another of you choic, who would it be? Please list the player's names and a short case of why. I know everyone thinks any number of guys ahould be in, but would you have the guts to boot someone out if it was up to you? As of right now I would bounce Gaylord Perry (overrated and a cheater) and replace him with Billy Pierce (one of the premeire left handed pitchers of the 50's and early sixties).
Who's next?

[bcbgcbrcb]

How about Maranville out and Vern Stephens in (same position).......

[barrysloate]

20th century: Bill Mazeroski out, Bert Blyleven in.

19th century: Tommy McCarthy out, Harry Stovey in.

Reasons: Blyleven and Stovey had better careers than the players they would replace.

[Jay Wolt]

Schoendienst out - Lefty O'Doul in

[iggyman]

Charles Comiskey OUT the Door! Marvin Miller in his place.

Red Schoendienst out and Bobby Grich in.

Lovely Day...

[Robextend]

Jesse Haines out, Blyleven in.

[steve B]

Alejandro Pompez out

He owned a couple teams, was a scout who signed some good talent like many scouts, and knew enough history to help pick some players for induction. And that's about it.

Dwight Evans in

Consistent batting not superstar batting, but if he'd hit 5 more homers he'd be in. Plus he was a great fielder, One of those guys that saved a lot of runs because of people not tagging up or trying and getting thrown out.

Steve B