Bruce Smith Autograph on a 55 Topps All Amer Card auto real or not? help!!

[cardcollectorguru]

I picked up this Bruce Smith autograph Topps 1955 All American card about 6 years ago. I was told by the Ebay seller that its authentic, i don't remember who i purchased it from since its been so long. To my knowledge it looks good to me. I haven't sent it to PSA/DNA yet because the fee to authenticate it is $150 but just wanted someones expertise opinion. I own high end autograph items that are PSA/DNA and JSA authenticated. I'm educated enough on auto's, but Bruce Smith is a toughie . Any help on opinion would be appreciated.


Thanks for looking,

cardcollectorguru

[MooseDog]

That doesn't look anything like what I got in person circa 1990 or so.

[Jay Wolt]

Originally Posted by MooseDog

That doesn't look anything like what I got in person circa 1990 or so.

The Bruce Smith that is pictured on the 1955 card died of cancer in 1967

[MooseDog]

Originally Posted by Jay Wolt

The Bruce Smith that is pictured on the 1955 card died of cancer in 1967

D'oh!

Withdrawn...

[cardcollectorguru]

yeah this is Bruce Smith the Heisman winner not Bruce Smith from the bills

[mschwade]

Originally Posted by cardcollectorguru

yeah this is bruce smith the heisman winner not bruce smith from the bills

lol

[mschwade]

Originally Posted by cardcollectorguru

I picked up this Bruce Smith autograph Topps 1955 All American card about 6 years ago. I was told by the Ebay seller that its authentic, i don't remember who i purchased it from since its been so long. To my knowledge it looks good to me. I haven't sent it to PSA/DNA yet because the fee to authenticate it is $150 but just wanted someones expertise opinion. I own high end autograph items that are PSA/DNA and JSA authenticated. I'm educated enough on auto's, but Bruce Smith is a toughie . Any help on opinion would be appreciated.


Thanks for looking,

cardcollectorguru

Too upright for my liking.

[bender07]

Another place to get opinions would be here. These guys collect college and pro football hofers.

[prewarsports]

EXACTLY what I was thinking. I have owned some Smith autos and actively look for them and the first thing that caught my eye was the slant. He has a nice slant to his signature in every one I have ever seen and this one is very upright. I also dont really like the "r" and how it appears to loop down on the shelf.

[dwr11]

Numerous examples of his signature can be found on Lelands site. Look in the December 2005 auction. This was the auction where Smith's family sold many of their items including a number of signed photos.