Winnings from Goodwin??

[mrvster]

Hello all....


Unfortunately i didn't win the Jacklitsch proof last night went well otta my range over 5 k w/ the juice

prices went a little crazy....the blank back even went real high

anybody else try for the proof and comisurate w/ me??
Show your winnings!!
Peace

Johnny

[OldSchoolBaseball]

I thought the T3's went really cheap - great pickup for those who collect them.

[jp1216]

Any way to see what time it finally ended this morning? I called it a night too early...

[bcbgcbrcb]

I was hoping for the T210 Stengel but the bidding got too high for me and I dropped out early.

[Jim VB]

Originally Posted by OldSchoolBaseball

I thought the T3's went really cheap - great pickup for those who collect them.

I don't disagree, but I thought he started those T3s awful high. 10-12 ended with 3 bids or less.

I realize it's a compromise for an auction house to pick a starting point, but Bill seems to be leaning toward the high starting point.

[Mikehealer]

How about the Chance Hindu selling for $4200+, nice looking card but that seems way over the top.

[Rob D.]

Originally Posted by bcbgcbrcb

I was hoping for the T210 Stengel but the bidding got too high for me and I dropped out early.

That's interesting, Phil. I thought the buyer got a great deal at that price.

[lharri3600]

won 1 sler, bid on 4

[ChiefBenderForever]

I just woke up happy as a pig in S*&^ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ju-ju Ju-ju Ju-ju !!!!!

[bcbgcbrcb]

Rob:

Compared to previous sales, that may be true. I guess I've been hoping for a "miracle" as I am waiting it out to pay around $5K for one in low-grade.

[mrvster]

Mike,

Your right....did you see the chance hindu??

David R....did u get any??

CONGRATS LARRY!!
WHO WON THE PROOF??
has to be a net 54er

[cozmokramer]

I bought the T216 Bender SGC 50

[OldSchoolBaseball]

Originally Posted by Jim VB

I don't disagree, but I thought he started those T3s awful high. 10-12 ended with 3 bids or less.

I realize it's a compromise for an auction house to pick a starting point, but Bill seems to be leaning toward the high starting point.

6's selling at $1,100-$1,300 when 3-4 years ago they were $3k-4K. Wow!

[kcohen]

Originally Posted by OldSchoolBaseball

6's selling at $1,100-$1,300 when 3-4 years ago they were $3k-4K. Wow!

How many of those were in Maestro auctions?


Ken Cohen

[DavidW]

At one time I was thinking of collecting the e103 set. Recent post here even suggested the prices were down. Goodwin prices were well above what I would have expected.

[OldSchoolBaseball]

Originally Posted by kcohen

How many of those were in Maestro auctions?


Ken Cohen

No........REA. I think if those were in REA they'd get much more

[yawie99]

Yeah, the E103 prices were pretty strong. I would've liked to have added the Bender or Collins but they went for more than what I was expecting. The commons did really well too. The Chase was probably the only one that did not do really well, but it was a bit washed out looking. Still better than mine, but I'm not ready to spend on upgrades yet.

Nice Kotton Bender, by the way. That was on my short list, but until Uncle Sam pays me back, I don't think I can swing that kind of card.

[Jim VB]

Originally Posted by OldSchoolBaseball

6's selling at $1,100-$1,300 when 3-4 years ago they were $3k-4K. Wow!

Yep! But in some cases, he had the starting bids the same on the PSA 1-PSA 3 as he did on the PSA 5s.

Certainly some deals to be had there.

[Touch'EmAll]

T206 Cobb greeen PSA 8 - about $65k
1917 Joe Jackson - about $75k

Wow!

I did pick up the Colgans Chip Cy Young PSA 8.5 - highest ever graded.

Did I mention the highest ever graded - Woo Hoo !!!

about 1400. with the juice - not too bad

[peterose4hof]

I thought the Babe Ruth E220 National Caramel ($846) went pretty low considering it's relative scarcity. I guess there just aren't many collectors for these.

http://www.goodwinandco.com/LotDetai...abe-Ruth-SGC-1

[glchen]

I picked up the E220 Ruth, the W512 Ruth, 1910 W-UNC Notebook and a couple of PSA6 33 Goudeys (56/109). I had a few items consigned for the auction, which received prices that I was happy with, and was close to the price of the items I won. In a way, it was like a net trade for me.

[tbob]

I picked up an E97 PSA 3 Kroh for about a third of what it was selling for just 2 years ago. Kroh is one of the tougher commons in the set. I had planned on picking up the T211s but when prices started stretching out late, I decided to save my money for the Legendary Auction.
Congrats to all who won lots, especially the E94 Wagner which has nice eye appeal despite the low grade.

[carrigansghost]

Nice UNC uncut, Gary.

Rawn

[mrvster]

Congrats on all those fine pick-ups

[pcoz]

I'm new to the board and want to thank everyone for all the incredible info. you've all contributed. I picked up the E94 Wags last night. Thought I may have overpaid a bit, but agree with tbob on the eye appeal being solid.

[kcohen]

I "won" this one.

n162 Glasscock.jpg

[philliesphan]

Originally Posted by mrvster

anybody else try for the proof and comisurate w/ me??

Johnny

I was underbidder on the Proof, so I can definitely commiserate. Interestingly, I'm confident that there are actually two T206 Jacklitsch proofs out there, and the other one is nicer.

I do own a Bransfield T206 proof, and will be quite happy with that, given the price shown in Goodwin.

m

[philliesphan]

the Burgess Nash Oscar Dugey card. Got it for the "minimum" bid. Frankly, I simply never see this back -- and particularly not of any Philadelphia Phillies.

[nolemmings]

I picked up a couple of m101-4 Sporting News HOFers in PSA 7--- Baker and Bender, each of which went for a little less than I expected, as did the Brown, Evers and especially the blank-backed m101-5 Marquard.

[sb1]

Paid way more than I thought I would have to, but it is a one year issue only and I might not come upon another anytime soon. Interestingly the cabinet reads "Gasper" and all of the checklists and Sporting Life ads have Gaspar, so there may well be a correct and incorrect version. #310 on the eternal quest. This is the before version, who thinks it looks better out of the slab??

[nolemmings]

who thinks it looks better out of the slab

I do, fer sure.

[kcohen]

Originally Posted by sb1

Paid way more than I thought I would have to,

Don't we always, Scott?

[calvindog]

[bcornell]

I won 2 CJ HOFers (Mack and Huggins), a couple of T204's (Huggins and Devlin), and the E100 Moore. I resist all urges to be a type card collector, but that last one was too tempting.

The 19% vig in Goodwin's is too high for both consignors and bidders, imho. I'd gladly forgo getting the catalogs if it meant that could be reduced.


Bill

[DJR]

.

[sox1903wschamp]

Managed to pluck a low hanging T3 (Niles).

[oldjudge]

David-The amazing thing about the N162s was that most were overgraded--check out the backs.
Did anyone here win the Red Hindu Ganzel?

[DJR]

.

[CMIZ5290]

I was able to pick up t206 marshall bvg 8 for what i thought was a decent price. There has only been 1 graded higher than a psa 7.

[Gradedcardman]

I picked up the t206 young portrait and the power horizontal. Missed out on all the rare backs.