Question on return policy

[pt7455]

Not sure if this is the right section but hoping someone can help.
I have a somewhat unique question and was hoping someone can give me some information.
How long does a person have legally to return a card they purchased if they find out its a reprint of non-authentic?
Some background cash purchase 3 years ago. I know I probably have no recourse but just wanted to check.
Thanks in advance for any feedback.

[bnorth]

Is it a counterfeit card? Reprint of non-authentic

Unless something was discussed I believe you own it the second you paid for it. You can force a refund from whoever you used to transferred the money but you are WAY past that time limit.

All you can do is ask but I doubt many dealers can remember a transaction from that long ago.

[Peter_Spaeth]

I can't imagine you have a "right" to return the card. That said, some jurisdictions have quite long statutes of limitation for breach of contract actions, if the transaction is significant enough that you might pursue a suit.

[pt7455]

Here is the issue cash deal no terms were discussed and 3 years have gone by. Not sure of what the law is In California where the transaction took place but assuming the time that has passed will be the issue???


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[CA Esq]

Originally Posted by pt7455

Here is the issue cash deal no terms were discussed and 3 years have gone by. Not sure of what the law is In California where the transaction took place but assuming the time that has passed will be the issue???


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

In general, there is no legal requirement that a seller must accept returns, unless the contract between the parties allows for returns. There are exceptions to this general rule like automobile purchases, etc.

If the item you purchased is fake, you might consider a small claims case. In California, if there is a written contract for this transaction, the statute of limitations is 4 years. If this was merely an oral contract, then the statue of limitations is only 2 years.

If we are talking $10k or less, this is a small claims issue.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by pt7455

Here is the issue cash deal no terms were discussed and 3 years have gone by. Not sure of what the law is In California where the transaction took place but assuming the time that has passed will be the issue???


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

What was the card? Was it a big long time dealer? Have you made them aware of the problem and asked for a refund? Post a pic of the card and describe why it is bad. I am sure I am not the only curious(nosey) person.

[steve B]

Most people wouldn't take it back.

I do think if it's memorably expensive you have a chance.

The stamp/coin/card guy I hang out at in college took back a bad coin something like 10 years after selling it. He did remember the fairly regular customer, AND the coin. No reciept, but they both recalled the sale as being "about $x" so that's what got refunded on the spot. The altered coin went off to the smelter.

I might ask, expecting nothing.

[todeen]

Originally Posted by bnorth

What was the card? Was it a big long time dealer? Have you made them aware of the problem and asked for a refund? Post a pic of the card and describe why it is bad. I am sure I am not the only curious(nosey) person.

Agree with Ben. If the seller is a regular dealer, and you are a regular customer, there is a chance seller will find a way to make right. But it might not be a cash return, it could be in store credit.

Sent from my SM-G9900 using Tapatalk

[NiceDocter]

Doesnt hurt to ask in a respectful way..... I know if I sold or traded something to a person that turned out to be not as it was supposed to be, I would probably do something to make the other person more whole, whether that would be a refund full or partial or another card or item. Many people have honor.... but not all. And Ive found that some will try and use your own honor against you as a weapon of guilt..... all that said, be nice, be respectful.... youve nothing to lose at this point. You may be pleasantly surprised....

[pt7455]

Thanks to everyone for the advice. Expecting nothing and hoping for the best!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk