This psa Mathewson slab look off to anyone else?

[Steve D]

Originally Posted by obcbobd

A card very similar to it is on the PSA Website





But I don't think it matches 100%, especially the corners

That's definitely the same card.

According to the PSA website, it was just sold 4 months ago by Levi B at 707 Sportscards!

Here's another one that Goldin sold in 2013. It has a very similar missing top-right corner, but is infinitely better looking; and it was graded a "1" (correctly, IMHO):



Steve

[BeanTown]

Originally Posted by Steve D

That's definitely the same card.

According to the PSA website, it was just sold 4 months ago by Levi B at 707 Sportscards!

Here's another one that Goldin sold in 2013. It has a very similar missing top-right corner, but is infinitely better looking; and it was graded a "1" (correctly, IMHO):



Steve

Maybe Moser bought it to crack out and resubmit to PSA for a two grade bump based on what the 2 looks like. Lol Nothing like consistancy from PSA if both those examples are legit.