Memory Lane's Catalogue?

[Archive]

Posted By: Jack Richards

Have any of you noticed anything weird with the Catalogue for Memory Lane's Sept 15 Auction?

I have only looked at it quickly -- and maybe I'm missing something -- but they seem to have vastly overstated the rarity of at least three fairly high priced cards:

LOT 498, 54B Mays , PSA 9. They state three times that there is only one PSA 9 1954 Bowman Mays (" The Only PSA 9...The Only PSA 9 known...only PSA MINT 9 Bowman known..."). That's not even close. According to the current Pop Report, there are 18 1954 Bowman Mays graded PSA 9.

LOT 705, 60T Wynn, PSA 8. They state that "No PSA known grades higher." In fact, there are 4 9's, each graded higher than Memory Lane's 8.

LOT 736, 61T Groat , PSA 9. They state that this card is "a low pop 2." Again, this is not even close. According to the current Pop Report, there are 15 61T Groats graded PSA 9...with 2 10's.

Am I missing something? If not, I don't understand how these kinds of errors could be made innocently.

I have raised the issue with Memory Lane and have not yet received a reply.