Buy the card, not the grade - stories

[DeanH3]

Great cards everyone. Jesse - That Mantle is off the charts.

[MattyC]

That PSA 6 ‘57 Mick is near the top of the long list of cards I deeply regret selling to Jesse over the years! One of many reasons I recently resolved never to sell a card again.

[pokerplyr80]

I'm sorry to hear that Matt, it's much easier to find a dead centered Mantle by waiting for you to upgrade than to search through 100s of Ebay and AH listings. I certainly understand your decision though.

[jb67]

[QUOTE=DeanH3;1834960]Great cards everyone. Jesse - That Mantle is off the charts.



DeanH3,

I can't imagine there is a better looking PSA 1 of a 53 Mick than this. That Mick is beyond belief.

[DeanH3]

[QUOTE=jb67;1835179]

Originally Posted by DeanH3

Great cards everyone. Jesse - That Mantle is off the charts.



DeanH3,

I can't imagine there is a better looking PSA 1 of a 53 Mick than this. That Mick is beyond belief.

Thank you David. Amazing how much a little back damage will save you.

[Exhibitman]

I bought this in a 2 holder



Cracked out and resubmitted it.

[GasHouseGang]

Wow Adam, that's crazy. It jumped from a 2 to a 7? That's ridiculous.

[irv]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

I bought this in a 2 holder



Cracked out and resubmitted it.

I remember that jump in grades, I just couldn't remember who posted it a couple years ago.
That one was an eye opener for me!

[sb1]

Here's one I believe. Nicer looking than most 3's and many 4's, no back damage either.

[irv]

Originally Posted by sb1

Here's one I believe. Nicer looking than most 3's and many 4's, no back damage either.

Wow! Very nice (undergraded, imo, as well) card.

I've posted this one a bunch too. Way undergraded, imo, but it worked out good for me as I got it at 3 prices.

I've always said/believe SGC grades harsher than PSA. My Crandall card being one them that only graded out a 5.