disclosure issues

[Archive]

Posted By: Peter Spaeth

Rather than clutter or offend Jay by slightly hijacking the Mastro thread, I will start a new one. Which, if any, of the following situations do people think should be disclosed by auction houses/dealers/private sellers (I assume the answer would be the same as to each class of seller but if not please explain).

1. Card was rejected for alterations by a grading service but, with nothing being done to it, subsequently was graded by the same service.

2. Card was rejected for alterations by a grading service but, with nothing being done to it, subsequently was graded by a different service.

3. Card was cracked out or resubmitted, with nothing being done to it, and received a higher grade from either the same or a different service.

4. Card was cracked out, improved, resubmitted, and received a higher grade.