1983 Topps 1952 Mantle reprint PSA

[bswhiten]

So I have two 1983 Topps Mantle reprint cards. They aren't valuable by any means, but my question has to do with were there really two variants of the card in the 83 set or is the psa 9 a reprint of a reprint? They both appear to be different card stock. My guess is psa mistakenly graded the 9 but just curious if anyone in here knows something I don't about this set. Thanks.

[slinger23]

My reprint card from the 1983 set looks just like the PSA 8 with the cream back and the blueish color on the front. My opinion is the one on the right is not from the 1983 set. I have sold two other sets in the past and they also had the cream back with the blue background the same way as the PSA 8.

[steve B]

Maybe the one on the right is from the 90's set that came in a couple formats of factory set?

I don't have any of either set, so Nothing to compare to.

Steve B

[Tripredacus]

The newer reprints are different on the back. I looked for a bit and could not find another reprint release having the same backs. But even in the pictures posted here, the backs look different besides the white. Where the card number in the baseball appears to be positioned differently.

Aside from the reprint sets themselves, apparently uncut sheets also had existed for these. Perhaps this other card came from a sheet?

http://toppsarchives.blogspot.com/20...-stitches.html

[bswhiten]

Thanks guys. I sent the pics to PSA so I will see what they say... Probably going to have to send in for reholder to really get a response.

[bswhiten]

Well I sent the card in question to PSA for a free review after I emailed them and the PSA 9 card is a fake. Nuts why would someone fake a reprint... I have to say though that customer service at PSA was awesome and is paying me for the price I paid.