Mantle/Maris/DiMaggio/Williams Ball Opinion

[quinnsryche]

I am sure I know the answer to this question but are ANY of these 5 sigs real? I just don't have enough experience with fakes to be sure. Any and all opinions pos or neg would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks,
Tony

[GrayGhost]

First Mantle looks pretty good, thats bout it IMO, other than Joe D possibly?

[Klrdds]

FWIW I would not be comfortable with it.

[Sophiedog]

I agree with Scott...1st Mantle looks good

[quinnsryche]

Here's another question, feel free to chime in. Let's say the 1st Mantle is good. It's on a ball with the Maris which we will say is not. What do I do with the ball? Can I sell it with one good and one bad signature? I have never done that myself or have seen anyone do that either. Any opinions greatly appreciated.

[Bestdj777]

Originally Posted by quinnsryche

Here's another question, feel free to chime in. Let's say the 1st Mantle is good. It's on a ball with the Maris which we will say is not. What do I do with the ball? Can I sell it with one good and one bad signature? I have never done that myself or have seen anyone do that either. Any opinions greatly appreciated.

If one of them is fake, I can't imagine that the other would be real. To the extent the Mantle is good but the Maris is fake, I'd still be a buyer depending on price as I only collect Mantle anyway.