Show off your best Under-Graded 2's & 3's

[Rhotchkiss]

A few days ago there was a lengthy thread about a T206 green Cobb PSA 3 that sold for a record price. While there were differing opinions on whether the price made sense, there was near unanimous agreement that the card is gorgeous and looks much better than the 3 given to it by PSA. So, with that in mind, lets see some low "graded" cards that appear much nice than their grades - by no means limited to T206s.

Below is my Magie Error PSA 3. There is a light crease in the bottom right, but man the card looks great, and in my opinion, should at least be 3.5 (for eye appeal), although I suppose the technical grade is accurate.

[irv]

[Mountaineer1999]

I think its better than a 1 but thats me

[Pat R]

Shown a couple of times before but it's my nicest 2.
Pasorius%20hindu.jpgPastorius%20Back b.jpg

[pherbener]

Buy the card, not the holder they say!!

[irv]

Originally Posted by Mountaineer1999

I think its better than a 1 but thats me

Anything with paper loss automatically puts it at a one, but I've always thought if it was on the back and the front still looked great, it should be noted or graded as such, but I suppose that is opening a whole new can of worms?

Originally Posted by Pat R

Shown a couple of times before but it's my nicest 2.
Attachment 278939Attachment 278940

Likely the stain for sure but like I said above.

Originally Posted by pherbener

Buy the card, not the holder they say!!

Is there paper loss or a stain in the lower left corner?

Either way, I'd have no trouble owning any of these cards.

[VintageBen]

PSA 2 because of a piece of tape residue on back. I bought it raw about 8 years ago and I didn't think that it would hurt the grade too bad. Still a great card regardless!!!

[TheBig6]