Are there any Montiel Propagandas experts out there?

[JoeDfan]

I got this raw 1946-47 Montiel DiMaggio in the mail today. I had the SGC one already, thinking I would send the new one in, and if it graded higher, I would keep that one and sell the other.

But then I noticed that the backs are different. So my questions for you experts are: Are there multiple variations of this card? If yes, is one version harder to find than the others?

I thought maybe the new one is counterfeit, but it is the right kind of paper (very thin), and under the microscope, the print dots look the same on both cards.

Ok, experts, help me out!

Thanks,
Sean

[bnorth]

They are both good just different backs.

[DBesse27]

Awesome cards!

[Harford20]

The Montiel cards can present both with different backs as you note, but also with different fronts. The borders can be seen in both a yellow border and an orange/red border. I have not found any specific singular front/back combos, although getting multiple cards of any single player is very difficult (just not enough numbers of cards out there).

Dave

[JoeDfan]

Thanks everyone!

[Snapolit1]

Originally Posted by Harford20

The Montiel cards can present both with different backs as you note, but also with different fronts. The borders can be seen in both a yellow border and an orange/red border. I have not found any specific singular front/back combos, although getting multiple cards of any single player is very difficult (just not enough numbers of cards out there).

Dave

Dave - is it safe to assume that the orange/red is scarcer than the yellow? Seems that way from my eBay trolling.

[Harford20]

Steve,
Again limited experience to only baseball in the Montiel set, and even more specific baseball Major League players in the set.

To answer your question, YES, in my data collection and cards I own, the orange/red border is about 20% of the Montiel's of a specific player and yellow the remaining 80%. Just as a caveat, these cards are often found with the border color removed and that may alter the data some.

Dave

[Snapolit1]

Originally Posted by Harford20

Steve,
Again limited experience to only baseball in the Montiel set, and even more specific baseball Major League players in the set.

To answer your question, YES, in my data collection and cards I own, the orange/red border is about 20% of the Montiel's of a specific player and yellow the remaining 80%. Just as a caveat, these cards are often found with the border color removed and that may alter the data some.

Dave

Thanks.