Jackie Robinson Autograph - FOR THE LOVE OF GOD HELP ME!!!! Fake or Real. Want Refund

[Tanman7baseball]

Hello everyone,

My question to you guys is to explain in detail of how this Jackie Robinson is FAKE. I am very certain it is fake after doing research. Unfortunately, I did this research after I bought it... Yes I know I was an idiot for buying it. Lastly, no it did not have a COA...

I am posting this, because I want my hard earned money back. I need someone to help me explain its inauthenticity, so I can justify returning this to the seller tomorrow. I am not going to spend $150 to get it denied by PSA... Also, I would like to print out your responses to show its not just me that believes this is a FAKE Jackie Robinson, but the opinion of many.

I purchased the Jackie Robinson autographed magazine last year out of IGNORANCE, TRUST, AND IMPULSE. Another fun fact, I found out it is not even Jackie depicted in the "run-down" on the cover. The man I bought this had multiple stories of ballplayers he met throughout his lifetime. He didn't care to send things into PSA or JSA, because it was expensive. Which usually I would just walk away, but his stories were so elaborate and believable that I stayed. I don't normally trust people, but the stories he told me about we're amazing. I love baseball and just listened with utter enjoyment. He is an autograph dealer from Topeka, Kansas. I bought this at a local card show in Oklahoma City. He said he obtained this piece off a dealer (apparently a wealthy accountant from Arizona).

Now please everyone who has knowledge on Jackie Robinson signatures can you please post everything you know about how this is not real.
I mean maybe I am wrong and it is real... Just someone can you please help!

Thank you all,

Colby

[Tanman7baseball]

Pics

[jjcollects]

definitely fake

[jjcollects]

Here is my authentic ball signed by the Brooklyn Dodgers in '49. match the letters they are very inconsistent with your sig. I would ask for refund.

[RelicSports]

I believe it is fake. The J, K, R, and N all look like they were written slowly and are not free flowing like most other signatures I have seen.

[GrayGhost]

Its terrible. letter formation is bad, especially the "R" and even the "J". And yes, no flow at all, drawn out.

Did the seller offer a guarantee? if it was sold "as is" you may be stuck with ti. NEVER buy a good autograph like Jackie's w/out researching or maybe posting it here, or PM'g one of the real experts on here, and giving them a fee for their help.

A hard lesson to learn for sure, hope u don't get stuck, but sadly, you might.

[jb217676]

Here's mine:

[doug.goodman]

I think it's real

[jgmp123]

Colby,

Sell it to Doug.

[mr2686]

Looks slowly drawn with some definite jitter to some of the letters. Most Jackie's you see, including mine, have a quickness about them with no jitters.
I wouldn't touch this one if it were me.

[Tuna82]

Originally Posted by jgmp123

Colby,

Sell it to Doug.

X2...classic.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by jgmp123

Colby,

Sell it to Doug.

That's a good one.

[khkco4bls]

this is my jackie pencil auto. from an autograph leather book with gil hodges, and 30 other autos.

[Tanman7baseball]

The guy was an asshole about the whole thing but I managed to get a couple ex-nrmt mantles (1960&1961)... All in all I'm just happy it is over with

[GrayGhost]

Originally Posted by Tanman7baseball

The guy was an asshole about the whole thing but I managed to get a couple ex-nrmt mantles (1960&1961)... All in all I'm just happy it is over with

Not bad. Just need to tread so lightly, especially with high dollar stuff like Jackie.