I think the card went very cheap. A creased SGC 2 sold for $313k in October of 2021. I would think a PSA 5 would be at least 2.5x an SGC 2, or $782k. Add 2.5 years to that last comp, 2.5 years in which the card market has gone nuts, and I think it should have been $1mm+.
I believe the card would have gotten much more in a US sports-card auction, and the consignor did themselves an expensive disservice here. Had Jay not outed the auction, the disservice may have been even more expense. |
Prices are a lot lower now than they were 2.5 years ago.
|
Quote:
|
I would venture out on a limb and say that card is presently worth 762k.
|
Quote:
But we will never know what could have been. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Yes, 2021 was a high point for some cards, but most certainly not for all, and many, including Ruth, are worth more today than 2.5 years ago. |
I was the underbidder. Just missed.
|
Quote:
|
Ruth Rookie
Quote:
|
Quote:
I follow 52's, and although there are outliers, not all have come down. Many, in fact have risen and continue to do so. |
Quote:
;) :) |
Ruth Rookie
Quote:
|
Re: High Grade Ruth Rookie
Quote:
|
Whoever bought that card is a genius and will easily double their money (if not far more) in next few years.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Re: Re: High Grade Ruth Rookie
Not saying that the auction result is "invalid" or that it isn't a valid comp. Point is that market value is not determined by an underbidder or lack thereof.
|
Who is the underbidder, to the underbidder?
Perhaps THAT is the new market value of the card, since the "over-bidder" is out of the picture now. Deep Thoughts! ;) |
Quote:
So do we start tossing out hammer prices arbitrarily or questioning them based on speculation? |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:52 AM. |