I agree Peter, but why have grading disparities? If you understand how to grade a card, it shouldn't be hard to be more consistent and accurate. It's doable.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Card B: was a 6, but dick Towle removed a wax stain. Gets a legit 7. Both sell for the same price. Which is worse again? |
I don't care about wax stains. Not what I am talking about.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Graders are just giving a "unbiased" opinion. It's subjective and there is literally no accountibility. So, if they give a bad grade who cares. If an attourney does something wrong or unethical then they are held accountable from the Bar of their State.
|
I was under the impression, perhaps misguided, that the half point grade designation was implemented to distinguish a card which has terrific eye appeal but a flaw from one that has a more obvious imperfection. My understanding with TPG grading is that a wrinkle, crease or small spot of paper loss, no matter how unobtrusive, will bring down the card's grade to a vg unless it is deserving of a half point bump, like beautiful green Cobb; it should be a vg+ for sure.
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:30 PM. |