From Willowgrove, who sent me an auction link.

Reulbach with the scratch up near the top.

Not great scans as they're from a lot and the original scan isn't all that big, but the important bit shows.

Steve B



http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...ictureid=21689
http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...ictureid=21688

Mr. Birmingham

Earlier in this thread a couple of board members posted up scans of two Hannifans (Piedmont 350) with lines on the backs.

I just noticed Frank B. posted this Demmitt on the BST with matching lines.

Below are one of the Hannifans & Frank's Demmitt.

The plate scratches seem to be taking on a life of their own!!

We can add Myers (fielding) with these lines.
Attachment 257744Attachment 257745

All three also have these marks.
Attachment 257746
Attachment 257747Attachment 257748

So we know these three were in the same sheet position on different sheets.

I found this new Kling scratch.
Attachment 269846
Attachment 269847

This was a probable scratch based on a Mordecai Brown with the same scratch.
Attachment 269848
Attachment 269849

There were two different existing matching scratches for Brown and Kling so
it was likely that this Kling existed.
Attachment 269850
Attachment 269852
Attachment 269853
Attachment 269854
Attachment 269855
For some reason there are very few scratches of certain subjects on this
sheet and kling is one of them. This is the first Kling with this scratch I have seen and I've
only seen one or two of the other two Kling scratches but I have several Brown's in my collection and I've seen quite a few others that have come up
for sale.
Attachment 269856
Attachment 269857

Nice find Pat and thank you for putting out this information!

I have a Kling PD 150 as well. When I get a minute, I'll take a look and see if mine has a scratch. I may have already looked for you earlier in this thread, but I'll check again.

Jantz

A bunch more

This card has probably been posted given the bold scratch, but just in case.

New Subject
 

I picked up this Clarke (Portrait) off ebay from a board member. This is the
first Clarke (Portrait) with a scratch and it's an exact match with the scratch
found on Flick.
Attachment 280627Attachment 280628
Attachment 280629Attachment 280630
Attachment 280631
Attachment 280632