Buy the card not the holder challenge
 

Which do you choose?

Attachment 221018

Attachment 221019

<p> OR </p>
Attachment 221020

Attachment 221021

I would buy the PSA 3. The PSA 2 has better eye appeal but that rotten spot on the card kills it for me.

Both are pretty rough for the grade. I'd pass on both unless I'd been searching for one for awhile. I've never seen a 2 with a pinhole before. I wouldn't be in any hurry to pay 2 money for that one.

+1

I often buy the holder but in this case I bought the card. The MK is a faint, half-inch ink mark on a deep black background on the back--in other words, only visible in certain light and at an angle. The card could have gotten a 5, and it's well-centered. I wonder if there's more than one or two better looking Duffys out there....http://www.net54baseball.com/attachm...1&d=1455338320

Wow great looking card Greg!

Not to be a broken record, but +2.

I would continue looking for another example...

Cheers,
Steve