PSA grading experts... Which Paige?
 

Hi there-

I’ve got a couple 53 Paiges. I was going to send to grade first, but thought I’d get opinions. I’m going to keep one and sell one. Do you think these return similar grades? And would they be better than PSA 1? One has centering issues, and the other has a small wrinkle in the cap area and the back has lots of paper loss. There as a sticky residue that was scraped off and it took some paper with it.

I like the eye appeal of the centered version better, that’s for sure. Just curious on the expert opinions. I am new to the grading stuff!

Certainly no higher than a 2 for either, but I'd think poor would be pretty harsh for either of them, IMO.

Expert here

I'd think the one on the left might grade a tad higher, but with an MC qualifier. 1.5(MC) or 2(MC) for the left and a 1 or maybe 1.5 for the right with that paper loss.

Both are pretty nice cards still. Good lower grade eye appeal!

Why not grade both?
In the future, upload the images somewhere else and make sure they're large enough to show the card on a zoom and have all the edges visible. I usually upload to Facebook first and then use the picture icon above the text box to enter it.

I would grade both. You can value them both at $99 and slip in under some kind of special.

Thanks everyone! I definitely need to figure out the picture uploading thing. Those were good scans but obviously didn’t upload as such.

Nice cards. I agree, get them both graded.

Members can always pm me for help in loading pics and things. Almost 100% of the issues pertain to the pictures being being from phones and too large to upload here. Carefully hosting from other sites and uploading here helps sometimes.
.

Get them both graded - it's Paige!

Jimmy

Agreed 1000%......that is an iconic card.