Opinions on Aaron, Teddy and Various HOF'er Rookies Sought...
 

I'm close to sending off a pile of autographs to get authenticated and slabbed (NOT graded), and was hoping some experts here could offer me some opinions on this grouping of players. Save for the Carlton RC auto (received in a trade from a 'Lefty' collector), all of these were done TTM many decades ago. Not planning on sending all of these in, just some/most of the 'good' ones.

The Aarons were received a few years apart (the pen differences tell which cards were together in the two SASEs), and the same 1975-1976 cards are accidentally shown twice. How concerned should I be with the vast differences in the signature? A ghost signer? Are some (or all?) a no-go??

My main concerns are with the big names/cards here. If anyone wishes to point to specific cards and LMK if it's 'thumbs up' or 'thumbs down,' I would greatly appreciate the input.

Thank you in advance!


These are some big-ass scans:

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...10294acf_k.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...65fc1890_k.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/4283/3...28b128d6_k.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/4256/3...2b2981ea_k.jpg


There is also a wide variety of other autographed cards in two of the albums in my bucket, if anyone has any interest in checking those out, too.

Reggie Jackson, Gary Carter, and Johnny Bench all look good to me. Don't know enough about the rest to give a qualified opiinion.

Not a fan of any of the Aarons or Williams

The Ted's are all not real.....sorry......

Bench, Seaver, Carter all good.

Definitely a no-go on Aaron or Williams. I believe Aaron always used a ghost signer for TTM. On the bright side, I believe the Schmidt's are real however he currently uses a ghost signer as well for TTM. Yours look legit though so he must have signed TTM himself when you got those autos.

Thanks for the opinions so far. I appreciate it (cue the bitter tear running slowly down my cheek).

On a very related note, if I send in autographs that 'fail,' PSA obviously won't refund the fees for those cards, correct? I would just be out that cash?

More bad than good here.....sorry

Correct.

Thank you!

Any time. Beckett same deal. Reject auto and keep cash. I get it. They did the work.