Net54baseball.com Forums - 1973 Topps Blue Team Checklists
Net54baseball.com Forums

Net54baseball.com Forums (http://www.net54baseball.com/index.php)
-   Postwar Baseball Cards Forum (Pre-1980) (http://www.net54baseball.com/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   1973 Topps Blue Team Checklists (http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=366710)

Vintagevault13 11-25-2025 09:41 AM

1973 Topps Blue Team Checklists
 
I am about to begin building the 1973 Topps set, but prices for unmarked blue team checklists are pretty crazy. For you set collectors, do you consider the set to be complete without the blue checklists? I am leaning that way since they aren’t numbered. Just interested in others’ thoughts. Thanks in advance. Happy Thanksgiving to all!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

johnlenhardt 11-25-2025 10:03 AM

I do not consider them a part of the set as they are not numbered. Would rather spend the cash buying cards I need. Otherwise I would but those last after I had the complete set as an alternative.

Harliduck 11-25-2025 11:50 AM

I have them for my set, but didn't and wouldn't have chased them except they were included in a lot I purchased when I started the set. I never remember ever seeing these as a kid, but I was only 3 when the set came out and only saw 73 cards from my buddies big brothers.

Were these a regular inserts into the packs?

Vintagevault13 11-25-2025 12:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harliduck (Post 2551819)
I have them for my set, but didn't and wouldn't have chased them except they were included in a lot I purchased when I started the set. I never remember ever seeing these as a kid, but I was only 3 when the set came out and only saw 73 cards from my buddies big brothers.

Were these a regular inserts into the packs?


It is my understanding that these were inserts in series 5 packs. They were also available as a mail-in offer. Like you, I don’t recall seeing them when I was younger, although I did not really begin collecting until 1974 so I did not have many 1973 cards as a kid.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Cliff Bowman 11-25-2025 01:25 PM

Not only do you have to get all 24 Blue Team checklists, you have to get both variations of each team with one or two asterisks on the back :D.

Rich Klein 11-25-2025 02:13 PM

IIRC these cards were not issued in "series" packs but in the test packs if all 5 series released in places like Ohio and Florida which got those packs. I know I got a good amount of them in a store in Orlando Florida circa 1993

nolemmings 11-25-2025 02:44 PM

They were not issued in the all-in-one series where I lived. Never saw a blue checklist for years.

jmoran19 11-25-2025 04:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich Klein (Post 2551846)
IIRC these cards were not issued in "series" packs but in the test packs if all 5 series released in places like Ohio and Florida which got those packs. I know I got a good amount of them in a store in Orlando Florida circa 1993

Correct, came in the all series wax packs

deweyinthehall 11-25-2025 05:58 PM

A few years ago there was a thread about these somewhere on these boards (I may have started it), and memories were all over the place about where and in what packs they were issued - I once heard someone only ever found them in series 5 racks. I didn't start collecting until '78 so it was before my time. A few years back I was lucky enough to nab an uncut sheet that would have been mailed out in response to the wrapper offer - it's pretty beat up, but I've never seen one before or since.

It would be interesting to see contemporary reporting (The Trader Speaks?) of manner of issuance - I know someone found an article a while back that demonstrated that the 1974 Traded cards were available from the start of the year, where most believed they had been a later issue.

Troy Kirk 11-25-2025 06:49 PM

I remember buying a sheet from the mail-in offer and then cutting it up when I got it, not a very good job of it either unfortunately.

jmoran19 11-25-2025 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by deweyinthehall (Post 2551890)
A few years ago there was a thread about these somewhere on these boards (I may have started it), and memories were all over the place about where and in what packs they were issued - I once heard someone only ever found them in series 5 racks. I didn't start collecting until '78 so it was before my time. A few years back I was lucky enough to nab an uncut sheet that would have been mailed out in response to the wrapper offer - it's pretty beat up, but I've never seen one before or since.

It would be interesting to see contemporary reporting (The Trader Speaks?) of manner of issuance - I know someone found an article a while back that demonstrated that the 1974 Traded cards were available from the start of the year, where most believed they had been a later issue.

There are a dozen or so legit YouTube series 5 wax packs being opened and none included the blue checklist

nolemmings 11-25-2025 09:58 PM

They were not in the all series packs in Minnesota. The southern part of the state anyway.

GasHouseGang 11-26-2025 01:43 AM

I collected the set a few years after the 1973 cards were issued and I never came across the blue checklists. I finally got some that appeared to be torn (unfortunately) from an uncut sheet. Are there factory cut versions or are they actually cut from the sheets that were offered?

stlcardsfan 11-26-2025 08:02 AM

1973 was my first year of collecting, is my favorite set and I have built 3 of them. I never considered the blue checklists part of the set. However, about 5 years ago I came across a complete set in EXMT/NRMT condition at a show and spent the $150 to buy it.

oaks1912 11-26-2025 11:10 AM

As posted above there is another thread on these from around a decade back. Below is that link. There doesn't seem to be much 'new' info added over the last ten years. But good to keep these threads linked together for future reference

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=184284

sb1 11-26-2025 05:17 PM

I did not have them as a kid, but felt obligated to include them in my current set.

butchie_t 11-26-2025 06:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cliff Bowman (Post 2551835)
Not only do you have to get all 24 Blue Team checklists, you have to get both variations of each team with one or two asterisks on the back :D.

And the uncut mail-in offer checklists. I’m still looking for that one.

Bigdaddy 11-27-2025 09:01 PM

I've got them in my 1973 set which was assembled many years ago, and would include them again if I was putting together a set today.

mikemb 11-28-2025 08:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bigdaddy (Post 2552160)
I've got them in my 1973 set which was assembled many years ago, and would include them again if I was putting together a set today.

Same here

Mike

Vintagevault13 11-28-2025 11:45 AM

Thanks for all of the insight. This set is sneaky interesting with the checklists and some of the questions surrounding the distribution of the cards. I may slowly add the checklists as I find good deals. Probably not going to worry too much about condition as long as they are unmarked.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

toppcat 11-28-2025 12:53 PM

4 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by GasHouseGang (Post 2551932)
I collected the set a few years after the 1973 cards were issued and I never came across the blue checklists. I finally got some that appeared to be torn (unfortunately) from an uncut sheet. Are there factory cut versions or are they actually cut from the sheets that were offered?

Excellent questions all around. It appears I cannot upload or attach images right now but have tried and maybe they will pop once site issues are resolved. I blogged about this a while back, here is the post: https://www.thetoppsarchives.com/202...ust-cards.html:

The blue checklists came in at least some all series packs and the retail box indicated this. The box commodity code is in red and has a 451 product number vs. 401 for cards issued in series. I'm not 100% clear on whether or not any packs can be found with the 451 codes and it seems they just used the 401's and inserted the checklists. They were experimenting and as with all things Topps, there will be variance in how things were issued.

I don't own a 73 premium example so can't say for certain but the card stock seems similar for both, see the attached image from a 2022 eBay auction I missed.

deweyinthehall 11-28-2025 01:08 PM

I have a set of the individual cards (not hand cut) and a premium uncut sheet - the stock is the same.

By the way - these pages have looked kinda strange on my end lately - no ones avatar images are showing up, posted images aren't always appearing, and a little question mark inside a black diamond pops up in posts where some sort of punctuation should be - I will try to copy and paste a sample from an earlier post on this thread here: " I don�t recall "

Is net54 about to explode or something??

PittOhio 11-30-2025 06:30 PM

Grew up in Ohio and got all the cards in one big series. The team checklists were included in the packs. Unfortunately I sold all my extras while setting up at shows, couldn’t figure out why one guy bought them all. To me they were very common, also didn’t know that the rest of the country was still buying by series and did not get the team checklists.

hornsz 11-30-2025 08:18 PM

I put together a set from packs in the Metro Detroit area from the corner store. Bought packs along with others on my block all summer as they were released in series in my area and none had blue checklists.

I consider them part of the master set


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:02 PM.